Version 1.1 of the definition has been released. Please help updating it, contribute translations, and help us with the design of logos and buttons to identify free cultural works and licenses!

Difference between revisions of "Talk:OSHW"

From Definition of Free Cultural Works
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with 'I like the spirit of the definition, but I would propose two amendments for clarity: * provides design files -> provides ''all relevant'' design files (otherwise hardware where …')
 
Line 5: Line 5:
  
 
--[[User:ChristianSiefkes|Christian Siefkes]] 16:02, 21 April 2010 (UTC)
 
--[[User:ChristianSiefkes|Christian Siefkes]] 16:02, 21 April 2010 (UTC)
 +
 +
I like that you're riffing off the Open Source Definition, but let me give you a heads-up that the OSD talks about the license under which software may be distributed.  The assumption is that if certain legal permissions are preserved, that the desired open source effect of collaborative development will occur.  That is not necessarily true.  Something more is needed, but we're not yet clear on how to put that into contract / agreement form.
 +
 +
[[Special:Contributions/128.153.100.220|128.153.100.220]] 14:57, 3 May 2010 (UTC) (Russ Nelson)

Revision as of 09:57, 3 May 2010

I like the spirit of the definition, but I would propose two amendments for clarity:

  • provides design files -> provides all relevant design files (otherwise hardware where only partial or incomplete design information is available would qualify)
  • software it has developed that is essential to the proper functioning -> necessary or required instead of essential ("essential" is a very strong word, potentially allowing to exclude software that is usually required, but not absolute essential under all circumstances)

--Christian Siefkes 16:02, 21 April 2010 (UTC)

I like that you're riffing off the Open Source Definition, but let me give you a heads-up that the OSD talks about the license under which software may be distributed. The assumption is that if certain legal permissions are preserved, that the desired open source effect of collaborative development will occur. That is not necessarily true. Something more is needed, but we're not yet clear on how to put that into contract / agreement form.

128.153.100.220 14:57, 3 May 2010 (UTC) (Russ Nelson)